At first glance, the three look like they’re trying to put out a fire, but their methods are very different. Analyzes each choice before giving the best answer.
Person No. 1 : Pouring water over a hot saucepan
This person makes the most dangerous mistake. If the skillet contains burning oil or fat, pouring water causes a violent reaction. Water instantly turns to steam, projects burning oil in all directions and can create a huge fireball. This significantly increases the risk of burns and fires.
Analysis: Very bad decision. This method aggravates the risk instead of eliminating it.
Step #2 : Cover the casserole with a lid
The second person chooses a method recommended by fire safety professionals. By covering the pan with a metal lid, it cuts off oxygen supply. Without oxygen, the flames progressively extinguish and the fire is extinguished with no risk of projection.
The next section on the next page
Analysis: This is the safest method for a stovetop fire contained in a saucepan.
Person #3: Use a fire extinguisher
Using a fire extinguisher can be a good idea, but it depends on the type. Not all fire extinguishers are suitable for kitchen fires. Some may project burning liquid or contaminate food. Again, a fire extinguisher specifically designed for grease fires is effective.
Analysis: Good reaction only if the extinguisher is suitable for the type of fire.
The most convincing answer: person n°2
She applied the recommended method for a casserole fire: smothering the flames by depriving the fire of oxygen. It’s the easiest, fastest and safest solution in this situation.
Final standings:
N°2 — The best answer.
No. 3 — Correct if the fire extinguisher is suitable.
No. 1 — The worst option, because water can cause a flame explosion.
